6 facts on Investing and Vegetarianism

Feb 11, 2022

David Quammen makes a very pertinent observation.

The writer and science journalist, notes that ALL the choices that we make, be it materialism or consumerism - has an impact. What we eat, how much we travel, how many children we have, what we buy, and so on and so forth. All these are personal choices, but they have consequences for our contact with the rest of the natural world because we are consumers of food, resources and energy.

Naturally, this should also get reflected in our decisions as investors.

Along the same lines, diet too is a personal choice, and a change in consumer habits and investment choices will go a long way. In this article in Enterprising Investor, which has been reproduced below, a case is made on how the investment community can help catalyze this revolution by encouraging Big Food to step up its game and become more healthy and sustainable.

(Similar to Big Pharma, Big Agriculture, and Big Oil, Big Food is characterized by the domination of a major market by just a few large companies. It is the multinational food and beverage industry with huge and concentrated power.)

FACT: The meat industry has a terrible carbon footprint.

Concerns about the associated environmental degradation, health implications, and ethics of meat consumption are prime motivators for increasing vegetarianism. Data shows that vegan and vegetarian food production is more resource-efficient and less taxing to the environment.

Animal-based food production and farming are among the leading contributors to climate change. Were the average American to replace their beef intake with plant-based alternatives, for example, they’d reduce their food-based carbon footprint by 96%. If the whole world made the switch from beef to vegetarian options, up to a quarter of the planet’s ice-free surface and up to 15% of global fresh water usage could be put to other uses, or not used at all. One kilogram of fruit requires one-fifteenth the amount of water to produce as the equivalent weight of meat.

Enough food is produced for everyone in the world to eat well, but because of our dietary habits, meat is overproduced and overconsumed in rich countries. This, in turn, crowds out our ability to grow the grains and produce needed to ensure healthy nutrition in emerging markets. Global agri-supply chains are also increasingly lengthy; Many food products travel hundreds of miles to get to our plates, further expanding our carbon footprint.

FACT: Our diets are addictive.

Big Food is big business and not easily disrupted. By persuading consumers to consume more and more calories, global agri-businesses have served their bottom lines. But the diets they’ve promoted have led to widespread obesity and an associated health crisis. They impose a social cost that we are only just beginning to calculate.

While our bodies require nutrition, Big Food designs products with precise combinations of sugar, salt, fat, and other additives that may be as habit-forming as tobacco or alcohol. Indeed, the food supply chain has some parallels with that of prescription opioids during the late 1990s and early 2000s. Food retailers and outlets are incentivized by Big Food to serve the demand despite the social costs just as doctors were incentivized by drug manufacturers to overwrite prescriptions.

Could the mainstream agri-industry and food retailers eventually face regulatory scrutiny? The sugary food and beverage industry in the United Kingdom already has. The crackdown on high sugar-content goods was led by government reviews which in turn influenced consumer demand. The meat industry may soon encounter a similar process.

FACT: In pursuant of profits, the environmental and social damage is real.

Several large, well-capitalized agri-business companies dominate the global food sector, including seed and grain production and final animal products. They compose a powerful oligopoly that dictates what we eat and how we eat it and where and how it is produced. They consume enormous amounts of global resources, heavily influence government policy, and contribute to a vast gap between developed and emerging countries.

Pursuing profit without accounting for the associated social and environmental production costs leads to short-term decision making. This has consequences for our natural resources and workforce health and safety. The use of fertilizers and pesticides may increase harvest yields, but it can also damage the surrounding ecosystems. Crop yields decline as the soil deteriorates. The knock-on consequence of focusing only on short-term growth, can lead to less developed countries facing depleted regional resources, deteriorating public health, and increased poverty.

FACT: Consumers and Investors can make a difference.

As consumers and investors, we have real power to change the current unsustainable model for the better. We need to educate ourselves on the origins of the foods we eat and the resources required to produce them. We need to cut down on — not necessarily cut out — foods that harm both us and the environment. Eating less meat, especially beef, or if possible, no meat at all, and sourcing more of our food from local suppliers are big steps in the right direction.

To be sure, there is a “chicken or the egg” element to this whole transition. If more appealing and affordable vegetarian and vegan products were available, more of us would switch to these types of diets. But green shoots are emerging. Change follows the money and more money will come when we achieve scale. The more flexitarians, vegetarians, and vegans there are, the more the food industry will innovate, reduce costs, and make non-animal food alternatives more accessible to more consumers.

FACT: The investment community has a key role to play.

Agri-businesses make up a substantial portion of retirement portfolios. Fund managers need to make sure that this sector is held to account. At the very least, fund managers should demand good governance and transparency on company carbon emission policies, workforce practices, and consumer health and well-being. Ideally, that means championing a board-level focus on sustainability and a clear roadmap to a less destructive, healthier, and more equitable food supply chain.

Of course, the value add of all of the above boils down to risk-mitigation and ethical considerations. These are important, but they’re not enough to ensure that an investment portfolio will meet our clients’ objectives. An investment that checks all the sustainability boxes but fails to generate returns is not a “good” investment in every sense of the word.

To reduce the environmental toll of food production, investment must flow towards more sustainable production systems. Access to such investments has historically been limited. Food tech is still a nascent industry and thus mostly the preserve of venture capitalists and private equity. But Sloane Ortel's Invest Vegan and other companies are forging a pathway to help investors better align their investing with their values. Beyond Investing’s US Vegan Climate Change exchange-traded fund (ETF) avoids companies that contribute to animal suffering, climate change, and environmental degradation. Elsewhere, food tech unicorns Beyond Meat and Oatly benefited from considerable hype en route to their successful initial public offerings (IPOs), showing, at the very least, that there is ample investor interest in these types of companies. And that investor interest is critical.

FACT: A green revolution is transforming our energy supply and waste management systems. A similar revolution needs to take place in global food production and in our diets.

The above has been taken from Put Your Money Where Your Mouth Is: Vegetarian and Vegan Investing

Read More on Environmental, Social and Governance - ESG investing.

Add a Comment
Please login or register to post a comment.
© Copyright 2024 Morningstar, Inc. All rights reserved.
Terms of Use    Privacy Policy
© Copyright 2024 Morningstar, Inc. All rights reserved. Please read our Terms of Use above. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
As of December 1st, 2023, the ESG-related information, methodologies, tools, ratings, data and opinions contained or reflected herein are not directed to or intended for use or distribution to India-based clients or users and their distribution to Indian resident individuals or entities is not permitted, and Morningstar/Sustainalytics accepts no responsibility or liability whatsoever for the actions of third parties in this respect.
Company: Morningstar India Private Limited; Regd. Office: 9th floor, Platinum Technopark, Plot No. 17/18, Sector 30A, Vashi, Navi Mumbai – 400705, Maharashtra, India; CIN: U72300MH2004PTC245103; Telephone No.: +91-22-61217100; Fax No.: +91-22-61217200; Contact: Morningstar India Help Desk (e-mail: helpdesk.in@morningstar.com) in case of queries or grievances.